'; } }) .catch(function () {}); } catch (e) {} })();

Smile Elements blog

The Arches We Stopped Using

Complimentary consultation with the orthodontist at our NW Calgary office. No referral needed. Treatment fees typically range from $3,000 to $10,000, and you receive yours in writing before you start.

Or call (403) 730-6400

An arch built from stacked grey stones, with one red stone at the top holding the others in place.

By Dr. Hisham Badawi, Orthodontist (certified specialist), BDS, DDS, MOrth, PhD, FRCD(C). About Dr. Badawi

Run your tongue along your lower front teeth. If they overlap more than they did ten years ago, you are not imagining it. Lower front teeth tend to crowd a little further with every decade of adult life, whether or not you wore braces as a teenager. Most people are told this is ageing. I have come to think it is something more specific: an arch that was never asked to work.

This is measurable. A study that followed people with naturally normal bites for 40 years, from about age 13 to 61, found that their incisors became more crowded and their arches shorter, with no treatment involved (Massaro and colleagues, 2018).

What we know

In populations that still eat traditional diets, crowded teeth are far less common. Anthropologists have documented broad arches with room for every tooth. When the same communities move to industrial food, crowding rises within a generation or two. Genes do not change that fast. Something in the environment did.

The best-supported explanation is load. Bone grows in response to the forces placed on it, and the jaw is no exception. Food that has been milled, softened and processed until it needs almost no chewing gives a growing jaw little reason to reach its full size. The teeth, whose size is set much more firmly by inheritance, arrive anyway. They have to fit somewhere.

This is not a fringe idea. Robert Corruccini described the pattern across world populations in 1984, and Daniel Lieberman’s work on the human head makes the same case from evolutionary biology. Animal studies on soft and hard diets point the same way.

What I am arguing

The second half of the story happens in the dental chair, and it is the part I think we have not measured.

The same refined diet that under-loads the jaw also feeds decay. It does so most reliably in the places a toothbrush cannot reach: the contact points where neighbouring teeth touch. Those contacts are not incidental. They are what holds a dental arch together, the way each stone in a bridge holds its neighbours in place.

When a contact decays, we restore it. That is good dentistry and I am not criticising the people who do it. But a restoration that comes back even a fraction narrower than the original tooth leaves a small space, and teeth do not tolerate spaces. The teeth behind drift forward to close it. The arch becomes slightly shorter, and that length does not come back.

One filling makes no visible difference. Several, over thirty years, might. My argument is that this cycle of decay, repair and drift is a quiet contributor to adult crowding that almost nobody tracks. I say “argument” deliberately. The mechanism is ordinary dentistry. Its size across a lifetime is, as far as I can find, unmeasured. I would like to see it measured, and I would like to do that work with general dentists, not at them.

What I am only asking

There is a wider question I cannot prove, and I will label it plainly as a hypothesis.

We put our feet in cushioned shoes. We put our spines in chairs for most of the waking day. We put our jaws on soft food. These are three structures built to bear load, and three structures we have largely stopped loading. Flat feet, stooped backs and crowded mouths are each studied in their own speciality. I wonder whether they are one story told three times.

I am not claiming that one causes another, or that treating teeth helps a back. I am asking whether a common cause, disuse, deserves a study that crosses those specialities.

What I will not tell you

I will not tell you that straightening teeth cures headaches, clenching or poor posture. The evidence does not support it, and you should be cautious of anyone who promises otherwise.

What I will tell you

Adult crowding is common. It progresses. It can be measured precisely, and it can often be addressed with a lighter touch than people expect. Sometimes the right answer after measuring is to do nothing and look again in a year.

In my practice, the orthodontist is the sole author of every prescription. Machine learning supports the clinical decision. It does not make it.

If you are an adult in Calgary and your teeth have moved, come and have them measured. Your first consultation is complimentary: book online or call (403) 730-6400. And if you are a clinician or a scientist who thinks I have this wrong, I would rather hear it in public. Bring data.

Sources: Corruccini RS. An epidemiologic transition in dental occlusion in world populations. American Journal of Orthodontics. 1984;86(5):419-426. Lieberman DE. The Evolution of the Human Head. Harvard University Press; 2011. Massaro C, Miranda F, Janson G, et al. Maturational changes of the normal occlusion: a 40-year follow-up. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. 2018;154(2):188-200.

Related: Clear aligners for adults · Who actually designs your aligner treatment?

Book your complimentary consultation

Leave your details and we will contact you within one business day. No referral needed.

Please don’t include health details here. We use this information only to contact you about booking your consultation.

What happens next: a member of our team contacts you within one business day, by phone or email, to arrange your complimentary consultation. Nothing is booked until you confirm a time.

Share this post

Picture of Dr. Hisham Badawi

Dr. Hisham Badawi

Book a complimentary consultation

In person with the orthodontist at our NW Calgary office. No referral needed. We reply within one business day.

Or call (403) 730-6400

You’ve Got Questions. We Are Here for You.

Smile Elements Orthodontics can provide compassionate treatment for your whole family. Book your complimentary consultation online or call our appointment desk at (403) 730-6400.